Why Use 4–20 mA Signal? | Comparison: 4–20 mA vs 0–10 V Signal
Why Use 4–20 mA Signal? | Comparison: 4–20 mA vs 0–10 V Signal
The 4–20 mA analog signal is widely used in industrial instrumentation due to its high reliability and accuracy in transmitting process values such as pressure, temperature, flow, and level.
1. Live Zero Detection
Using 4 mA as the starting point (instead of 0 mA) helps differentiate:
- 4 mA = 0% process value
- 0 mA = cable break / device fault
2. Prevents Signal Loss Over Long Distances
Current loops do not drop with cable length like voltage signals. Even with long cable runs, the current remains stable.
3. High Noise Immunity
4–20 mA loops are less affected by electrical noise, making them reliable in industrial environments with motors, VFDs, and heavy equipment.
4. Power + Signal on Same Two Wires
Loop-powered transmitters use the same pair of wires for power supply and signal, reducing wiring complexity and cost.
5. Supports HART Communication
The 4–20 mA signal can carry digital HART data on top of the analog signal for configuration and diagnostics.
6. Simple, Accurate & Industry Standard
The design is simple, stable, and suitable for long distances with high accuracy.
Comparison: 4–20 mA vs 0–10 V Signal
| Feature | 4–20 mA Signal | 0–10 V Signal |
|---|---|---|
| Signal Type | Current Loop | Voltage Signal |
| Live Zero Detection | Supported (4 mA ≠ fault, 0 mA = fault) | Not supported (0 V and fault look similar) |
| Signal Drop Over Distance | No drop — current stays constant | Voltage drops significantly with cable length |
| Noise Immunity | Very high noise immunity | More sensitive to electrical noise |
| Typical Distance | Up to several kilometers | Short distances only |
| Power + Signal on Same Wires | Yes (2-wire loop) | No |
| Wiring Complexity | Simple | Requires separate power and signal wires |
| Accuracy | High accuracy over long distances | Accuracy decreases with wire length |
| Common Applications | Industrial sensors, transmitters, PLC/DCS | Short-distance controls, lab equipment |
| HART Support | Yes (HART communication supported) | No |
Comments
Post a Comment